Footage displaying protected Scottish waters raked clear by scallop dredgers reveals that marine protected areas are “paper parks”, say campaigners
5 October 2022
A contemporary row has damaged out over the effectiveness of the UK’s marine safety schemes after proof emerged of a seabed in protected Scottish waters raked clear by scallop dredgers.
Earlier this summer season, marketing campaign teams Open Seas and Greenpeace despatched underwater drones to movie the seabed contained in the Small Isles Marine Protected Space (MPA), protected waters across the isle of Rum on Scotland’s west coast.
The footage suggests an space of maerl – a fragile, slow-growing type of coral – contained in the protected zone has been destroyed by dredging exercise, with the seabed diminished to a sequence of naked, furrowed tracks.
The teams say the proof is proof that the Small Isles MPA is a “paper park” that isn’t protected by bans on damaging fishing strategies.
It’s presently authorized for scallop dredgers and backside trawlers to fish on this MPA and dozens of others across the UK shoreline, regardless of protests by environmental campaigners.
“The vast majority of MPAs within the UK nonetheless don’t have any type of fisheries administration in place by any means,” says Phil Taylor, head of coverage and operations at Open Seas. “So they’re paper parks. And that is the worst instance of a paper park that we’ve got come throughout.”
The Small Isles MPA, designated by the Scottish authorities in 2014, is thought to be one of the vital necessary marine habitats within the UK. It’s dwelling to the uncommon fan mussel (Atrina fragilis) alongside fragile marine habitats equivalent to burrowed mud and maerl beds.
Two years in the past, the world of seabed surveyed by Open Seas and Greenpeace featured a “just about intact” carpet of maerl, says Taylor. Now the positioning appears like a “ploughed discipline”, he says.
Research have repeatedly proven that scallop dredging causes catastrophic damage to maerl beds.
Maerl is the European equal of a coral reef, performing as nursery environments for marine life, says Jason Hall-Spencer on the College of Plymouth, UK.
However they solely develop 1 millimetre a yr and so battle to recuperate from dredging actions. “These are 1000’s of years previous, these habitat varieties,” he says. “When you injury a maerl mattress, it gained’t develop again.”
The Scottish authorities is now beneath renewed stress to ban scallop dredging inside its MPAs, with Open Seas calling for an instantaneous ban.
Greater than a 3rd of UK coastal waters are lined by MPAs, however backside trawling is banned in simply 4.
In response to the findings, a spokesperson for the Scottish authorities stated fisheries administration measures will probably be launched to all its MPAs by 2024, together with the Small Isles MPA.
“The Scottish Authorities is set to guard our treasured marine setting and obtain and preserve good environmental standing for all of Scotland’s seas,” they stated in an announcement. “We take our duty to guard the marine setting significantly.”
Campaigners say imposing more durable fishing guidelines on protected habitats will drastically enhance the UK’s marine biodiversity. In Lyme Bay in Dorset, for instance, trawling and dredging had been banned in 2008 and the world has seen a dramatic revival in marine biodiversity.
Extra on these matters:
Discussion about this post